Here we go with the Top 10. Live.
My Grades So Far…
- Allison – A
- Matt G – A-
- Adam – A-
- Danny – B+
- Kris – B+
- Anoop – C+
- Lil – C
- Scott – C
- Michael – C-
- Megan – D
1. Matt G.
“Let’s Get It On”
I thought it was a really good performance. I loved, loved, loved how he started at the piano then got up and sang. He did a bit of an over the top sequence when he was up in front of the judges but other than that, it was a really good performance. Judges all loved him, too. No one’s stock has skyrocketed as quickly as Matt’s.
Grade: A-
2. Kris A.
“How Sweet It Is”
Another really good performance for a quick riser. It was great with the guitar, which didn’t overpower him. Judges as well loved it. Good vocal and his personality is contagious.
Grade: B+
3. Scott M.
“You Can’t Hurray Live”
Behind the piano in what is basically a slap in the face to Paula’s advice. Paula’s defensive when confronted with this fact. It’s not a good performance. He just doesn’t have the vocal skillset to compete with the front runners. All of the judges with the exception of Kara (who liked the tempo of the song) didn’t think too fondly of it.
Grade: C
4. Megan C.
“For Once In My Life”
Yikes. That was ugly. Terrible song choice. It does nothing for her good, quirky voice. All the judges agree. She’s in the bottom three, for sure.. and a good chance to leave.
Grade: D
5. Anoop D.
“Ohh Baby Baby”
It was a bit of a dip down from last week’s AMAZING performance. It was a boring performance though… too slow for my taste but the judges all agree, for the most part, that it was the second straight week of a good performance for Noop-Dawg.
Grade: C+
6. Michael S.
“Ain’t Too Proud To Beg”
I thought it was borderline okay and certainly thought it was good enough to stay especially after Megan’s bomb but the judges are currently ripping on song selection and vocals. Kara notes that he’s not an artist. Simon thinks he has no chance to win it, which is true. I think we have the second part of our bottom two.
Grade: C-
7. Lil’ R.
“Heat Wave”
I’ve always thought that Lil had amazing vocals but this performance, so far, seems like she’s yelling the song, which she has done since Day 1 but for some reason tonight is the first time I’ve noticed. She’s sporting a new hair-do, too. I get the feeling the judges will love it. Randy thought the front half was bad, which I absolutely agree and doesn’t think it’s her best performance. Kara agrees and takes the you’re beautiful road and has some harsh words.. saying that this was the week to show us that she is the diva they all think she is, but she doesn’t think she accomplished that.. and noticed the screaming. Paula disagrees. I tuned out after that. Simon thought it was an authentic tribute to Motown but didn’t think it was a good song choice.. notes that she is one of the best singers in the competition.
Grade: C
8. Adam L.
“Tracks of My Tears”
The pre-song clip shows Adam singing a very sweet version of the song. This may actually be good. His hair is terrible… looks like Taylor Hicks with the way the light hits his hair. There’s no screams or screeching but he’s taking some notes unnecessarily high… which is Adam’s MO. People are either going to love or hate his last note that lasted about 10 seconds. Paula loves it. Kara stands up for that performance and calls it one of the best of the night.
Kara: “I’ve got 6 words for you. One of the best performances of the night.”
That’s 8 if I’m not mistaken. Simon disagrees with Kara… it was the best performance of the night. Randy loves it too. I don’t have quite the lovefest but it was definitely better than last week.
Grade: A-
Up Next: Danny
“Get Ready”
Danny’s pre-performance clip shows a lot of promise. This should be good.. Danny is full of soul. The song seems a bit fast to start but Danny’s catching up and really doing well with this song. He even dances with the backup singers. Props. I think he batted this one out of the park. They’re running short on times, which is disappointing. Paula likes it. Simon thought it was clumsy and amateurish. Randy didn’t think it was his best but he loved the energy. Kara thought it was good but still a huge fan.
Grade: B+
10. Allison I.
“Papa Is A Rolling Stone “
Closing the show is 16-year old (so hard to believe), Allison. Immediately that smoky (pun intended) quality to her voice comes through. There’s no way this girl is 16 with a voice as good as this. Paula’s up and about…. again. That was a very, very, very good performance. Randy thought it was “blazing hot”. Kara is having an orgasm… very energetic in her comments. Paula, with a mustache Simon drew on her, thought it was good as well. Simon calls her a survivor. One of the best she’s ever done.
Grade: A